As I read Ben Sheffner’s tweets about the Capital v. Thomas case with interest, I was struck by how quickly the jury issued its decision to award the record companies $1.92 million — about $1.7 million more than the original jury awarded. I instantly thought of this picture as I think both Ms. Thomas and her attorney are going to need plenty of this and some lucky lottery tickets.
From the music industry’s perspective, this was an important win. The stunning size of the verdict and the swiftness with which the jury came back with the award should please those who were tasked with the aggressive campaign against copyright infringement.
I agree with Sheffner that the judge will likely slash the jury’s award, but it shouldn’t come to that. As I mentioned in a previous post, winning the case is only the first step for the music industry. It has won the case and now it needs to win the public relations battle by not overreaching.
The music industry has every incentive to keep the decision from spinning into a public relations circus like what happened in the Pirate Bay case. It appears that Thomas and her attorney want to quietly put an end to this case so the record companies now have the opportunity to win the public relations battle. They can do so by not insisting on a settlement that results in financial ruin for Thomas, but instead reaches a confidential settlement that Thomas can live with.
Settlement will not undermine its message that although the Pirates of the Caribbean would have considered the copyright code to be more like “guidelines” than actual rules, the music industry politely and firmly begs to differ. “Welcome aboard the Black Pearl”, Ms. Thomas.